Was the Proteas world record ODI defeat to England just a blip, or a sign of deeper problems?
South Africa’s world record 342-run ODI defeat to England could raise questions about their short-format cricket performance, though it may be an isolated incident rather than a sign of deeper issues. Picture: Graham Hunt/ProSports/Shutterstock
Image: Graham Hunt/ProSports/Shutterstock
The Proteas may finally be World Test Champions, but they are now also world record holders for the biggest ever defeat by run in a One-Day International.
It begs the question, is the Proteas’ 342-run defeat to England in Southampton on Sunday an anomaly or a sign of a bigger problem for the team in short-format cricket? A question like this is fair after England posted 414/5 and then dismissed South Africa for 72 in their chase.
Of course, the three-match series was already decided after a dominant display by the visiting Proteas in the first two games, which meant the final clash was essentially a dead rubber.
However, the Proteas were not taking on an England team in good form. Aside from their ODI series whitewash over a weak touring West Indies in June, this side last tasted victory in a series in 2023 against Ireland.
Embarrassing or just a bad day at the office?
Proteas coach Shukri Conrad said after the match: “Any excuse is better than none. We were definitely off today. And against a top side like England, when you’re not on top of your game, you do get exposed.
“If we were going to be poor at something, we’d rather be poor at games that aren’t clutch games. We’re not making light of today’s defeat. That was slightly embarrassing.”
Proteas skipper Temba Bavuma was not quite as harsh as Conrad when he said: “There are shining moments, so we’ll try to highlight those. They can’t be wiped away by one performance.”
Ultimately, a day like that can happen in sport, and chasing a massive score meant the pressure was on from the start in the Proteas chase.
Add in a brilliant display from the England attack, and in particular from Jofra Archer (4/18), who on his day can be the best fast bowler in the world, and you have a recipe for disaster from a South African perspective.
Ultimately, it was a result which counted little and, like Bavuma suggests, probably is not worth over analysing.
* The views expressed are not necessarily the views of IOL or Independent Media.
** JOIN THE CONVERSATION: Send us an email with your comments, thoughts or responses to [email protected]. Letters should be a maximum of 500 words, and may be edited for length. Anonymous correspondence will not be published. Submissions should include a contact number and physical address (not for publication).